Константин Сонин (ksonin) wrote,
Константин Сонин
ksonin

Личная мягкая сила

Один профессиональный болтун написал недавно, что я слишком часто употребляю местоимение «я». Он, конечно, в данном случае прав. Записи в блоге если чем и связаны, то как раз личностью автора, так что, действительно, я про себя пишу больше, чем про что либо. И, наверное, больше чем нужно.

А тут у меня тут возникла идея измерить собственное "чисто интеллектуальное влияние" - собственную "мягкую силу". Случилось это так: в середине января я зашёл на диспут АНЦЭА двух представителей молодого поколения - Александра Либмана из ИЭ и Алексея Кузнецова из ИМЭМО о том, куда идёт российская экономическая наука. Там один из них сетовал, что наши учёные не публикуются по-английски, а другой - что результатами наших экономистов никто не интересуется...

Вот я взял и с помощью Гугла нашёл программы тех курсов в заграничных университетах, в которых в качестве обязательного или дополнительного чтения рекомендуются мои статьи. Что сразу удивляет - я почему-то думал, что только 2-3 статьи попадут в учебные программы, но попала, так или иначе, большая часть опубликованных статей.

Теперь вот думаю в целом – много получилось или мало? Есть хоть какое-то влияние или нет? Надо сказать, что программы многих курсов довольно быстро меняются (например, курсы про российскую политику), так что статьи десятилетней давности уже почти все выбыли из учебных курсов и с веб-сайтов (в частности, самая цитируемая моя статья не встречается в программах курсов). Однако интересно (и приятно), что наши статьи попали в пару десятков "классических" программ, которые читаются уже десятки лет (разного рода public choice и positive political economy). Интересен так же разброс - одна статья используется в курсах международных отношений. Впрочем, в новых, быстро развивающихся областях читать разные программы курсов ещё интереснее...


“Why Resource-Poor Dictators Allow Freer Media” (Сергей Гуриев, Георгий Егоров)

Public Economics II, University of Alicante, 2013
The Political Economy of China, Berkeley, 2008
Development economics: Comparative institutional economics approach, EERC Kiev, 2007
Comparative Authoritarianism, University of Oregon, 2010
Authoritarianism, Berkeley, 2011
The Political Economy of Natural Resources, University of Konstanz, 2012
Mass Media and Politics, Southern Illinois University, 2013
Collective Choice and Democracy, Ecole Polytechnique, France, 2012
Topics in empirical political economy of government and development, Paris School of Economics, 2011
• Democracy and Authoritarianism, U. Colorado, 2010
Comparative Political Institutions, Michigan State University, 2011
Core Graduate Course in International Relations: Conflict, NYU, 2011 (Bruce Bueno de Mesquita!)
Comparative Politics Survey, Columbia, 2012
Topics in the Economics of Politics, University of Miami, 2012
Politics and Media in Comparative Perspective, State University of Rio de Janeiro, 2013
Political Change: Regime Transitions, Revolutions, Protests, SUNY-Buffalo, 2013
Political Economy, University Pompeu Fabra, 2014
Public Economics and Political Economy, SciencePo, 2014
Politics under Authoritarianism, University of Florida, 2014
Markets and Institutions, Stockholm School of Economics 2013
Political Science Field Survey, Bocconi, 2014
Government and Regulation, Stocholm School of Economics, 2014
Democracy, UCSD, 2015
Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014


"Political Selection and Persistence of Bad Governments" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)

Foundations of Political Economy, Princeton, 2012 (Thomas Romer)
Collective Choice and Democracy, Ecole Polytechnique, France, 2012
Contract Theory and Applications, Wharton, UPenn
Political Economy II, University of Rochester, 2011
Public and Political Economics, Bavarian Graduate Program in Economics, 2012
Foundations of Political Economy, Caltech, 2011
Analysis of the Chinese Economy, CUHK, 2009
Dynamic Political Economic Theory, Stanford, 2012


"Coalition Formation in Non-democracies"(Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)

Political Economy of Development, Columbia, 2010
Institutions in Comparative Political Economy, PSU, 2011
Political Economy of Development, Rochester, 2009
Political Economy of Institutions and Development, MIT, 2012
Comparative Political Institutions, Michigan State University, 2011
Formal Models in International Relations, University of Wisconsin, 2012
Game Theory, University of Wyoming, 2014
Institutions in Economic Theory and Economic History, Heidelberg University, 2013
Selected Topics in Development Economics, Universitat Siegen, 2014
Political Economy of Economic Development, Harvard, 2015
Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014


"Dictators and their Viziers" (Георгий Егоров)

Political Economy of Development, Columbia, 2010
Comparative Political Institutions, University of Minnesota
Political Economy of Development, University of Rochester, 2009
Institutions in Comparative Political Economy, PSU, 2011
Political Economy of Political Institutions, NYU, 2011
New Institutional Economics, U. Massachusetts, Amherst, 2012
Comparative Politics, NYU, 2005
•  Comparative Political Institutions, Claremont Graduate University, 2011
A Short Course on Political Economics, Central University of Finance and Economics, Beijing, 2009 (Roger Myerson)
Topics in Positive Political Economy, Peking University, 2013
Institutions in Economic Theory and Economic History, Heidelberg University, 2013
Comparative Political Institutions, NYU
Politics of Dictatorships, Binghamton, 2015
Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014


"Dynamics & Stability of Coalitions, Constitutions, and Clubs" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)

Political Economy of Institutions and Development, MIT, 2012
Advanced Topics in Macroeconomics, U. Washington in St.Louis, 2013
Political Economy II, Rochester, 2011
Social Choice and Voting, Bocconi University, 2012
Dynamic Political Economic Theory, Stanford, 2012
Formal Models of Elections and Representation, Washington University, 2013
Economics of Institutions, Norwegian School of Economics, 2014
Formal Political Theory II, Harvard, 2014
Social Choice and Voting Models, Northwestern, 2015


"A Theory of Brinkmanship, Conflict, and Commitment" (Майкл Шварц)

Formal Models in International Relations, UCSD, 2004-11
Theory and Methods in International Relations, Texas A & M, 2009


"Determinants of Nationalization in the Oil Sector" (Сергей Гуриев, Антон Колотилин)

Analysis of the Transitional Economies, University of Washington, 2010
Natural Resource Economics, UCSB, 2011


"Development Based on Commodity Revenues" (Сергей Гуриев, Александр Плеханов)

Analysis of the Transitional Economies, University of Washington, 2010
Post-Soviet States and Markets, Columbia, 2010


"Capture of Bankruptcy" (Екатерина Журавская, Ариана Ламберт-Могилянская)

Business and Politics in Eastern and Central Europe, U. Rochester, 2010
• Aktuelle Forschungsfragen der russischen Volkswirtschaft (Topics in the Russian Economy), Frei University, Berlin, 2007
The Former Socialist Economies and Transition, University of Pittsburgh, 2007


"Dictators and Oligarchs: A Dynamic Theory of Contested Property Rights" (Сергей Гуриев)

Topics in Law and Economics, CEU, 2009
Analytic Narratives: Research Methods in Economic History, Political Economy and Development, George Mason University


"Businessman Candidates" (Скотт Гельбах, Екатерина Журавская)

Business and Politics in Eastern and Central Europe, U. Rochester, 2010


"A Political Theory of Populism" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)

Topics in Political Economy, University of Maryland, 2012 (Allan Drazen)
Topics in Political Economy, Lombardy Advanced School in Economic Research, 2012 (Massimo Morelli)
Political Economy of Institutions and Development, MIT, 2012
Advanced Microeconomic Theory, Duke University, 2013
Formal Political Theory II, Harvard University, 2014
Formal Models of Elections and Representation, Washington University, 2013


"Incumbency Advantage in Non-Democracies" (Георгий Егоров)

Comparative Elections and Voting, WKU, 2014


"Political Model of Social Evolution" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)

Approaches to Development, Carleton College, 2012
Foundations of Political Economy, Princeton, 2012 (Thomas Romer)


"The Killing Game" (Георгий Егоров)

Collective Choice and Democracy, Ecole Polytechnique, France, 2012
A Short Course on Political Economics, Central University of Finance and Economics, Beijing, 2009 (Roger Myerson)


"Rational dictators and the killing of innocents: Data from Stalin's archives" (Пол Грегори, Филипп Шрёдер)

Aktuelle Forschungsfragen der russischen Volkswirtschaft (Topics in the Russian Economy), Frei University, Berlin, 2012
Economics of Non-market Decision Making, George Mason University, 2014
Political Economy of Russia, Harvard, 2014
Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014
Analytic Narratives: Research Methods in Economic History, Political Economy and Development, George Mason University


"Political Economy in a Changing World" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)

Macroeconomics II, Bogazici University
Social Choice and Voting Models, Northwestern, 2015


"Do Juntas Lead to Personal Rule?" (Дарон Асемоглу, Георгий Егоров)

Analysis of the Chinese Economy, CUHK, 2009
Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014


"Social Media and Corruption" (Рубен Ениколопов, Мария Петрова)

Aktuelle Forschungsfragen der russischen Volkswirtschaft (Topics in the Russian Economy), Frei University, Berlin, 2012
Information Communication Technology, Economic Development, and Political Violence, Princeton, 2014


"Government Control of the Media" (Скотт Гельбах)

• Public Economics II, University of Alicante, 2013
Non-democratic Politics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2014


"Field Experiment Estimate of Electoral Fraud" (Алексей Захаров, Рубен Ениколопов, Василий Коровкин, Мария Петрова)

• Topics in Russian and Eurasian Studies: Political Economy of the Russian Transformation, University of Toronto, 2013
Political Economy, University Pompeu Fabra, 2014
Political Science: Election Forensics, University of Michigan, 2014
Russian and Post-Soviet Politics, University of Wisconsin-Milwakee, 2014
The Politics of Authoritarian Regimes, University of Wisconsin-Milwakee, 2013
Introduction to Comparative Politics, UCLA, 2014


"Endogenous Property Rights" (Даниэль Дирмейер, Георгий Егоров)

Comparative Political Economy, University of Konstanz, 2014
Social Choice and Voting Models, Northwestern, 2015


"The End of Economic Transition"

Economic Georgraphy, University of Southern Denmark, 2014


"Why the Rich May Favor Poor Protection of Property Rights"

Economic Models of Politics, U.Chicago, 2006 (Roger Myerson)
Economics of Transition, Berkeley, 200? (Gerard Roland)


"Collusive Market-Sharing and Corruption in Procurement" (Ариана Ламберт-Могилянски)

Public Procurement in a Globalized World, Университет Лиссабона


Газетные колонки, выступления на круглых столах

• EU-Russia, Science Po, 2012
Russian Government, Palacky University
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 47 comments